237 Comments
User's avatar
Jason's avatar

I'm sure most people reading this are closer politically to Waj than to Mike (like I am), but really they agree on much more than they disagree.

Mike deserves a lot of credit too. I follow him here as well, and he regularly goes into the lion's den at Fox, Newsmax and other hard right wing outlets and defends progressive points while being called a crazy left winger all the time.

One of my big questions for him would be - Mike, you often mention the 'median voter'. I wonder if this person really, truly exists? Are there really a significant number of 'swing voters' who change parties back and forth, or are there people that vote sometimes and not other times based on how excited or discouraged they are to vote?

Or put another way, are 'median voters' more important than voter enthusiasm, particularly the enthusiasm of the base? From what I can see lately, it is not. Mamdani didn't win New York by appealing to the mythical middle, although he did and does speak all the time on issue that affect nearly everyone...he had an incredibly enthusiastic base of support that started from dedicated, grassroots DSA campaigners and grew from there. Turnout for the primary and the general election here for mayor was huge.

But, Mike knows what he's talking about when talking about elections. I think his point of view is very valuable. I love the convos with him and Waj, too often do we all listen to people we agree with on everything. US on the left need to deliver our arguments to people who have a different point of view, or we won't grow as a movement.

UrbanGirl57's avatar

I respect the heck out of Mike for going into the lion's den/Hellscapes of those places. And I love that he is out there on Substack 👍

LadyLA's avatar

Middle Americans are backwoods crazy. They need to get out of their towns or cities. They are conservative because they don’t know better and they’ll continue being backward conservatives if they continue voting the way they do. The middle needs to wake the eff up!

Jason's avatar

What are 'middle Americans'? Like moderates, or you mean like the Midwest?

I can say the Midwest has some of the strongest progressive places in the country, like Madison, Minneapolis, really many of the upper Midwest cities...

Here in NYC, lots of progressive voters but also some pretty hardcore right wing bastions too. We did somehow elect that dirtbag Giuliani a couple times.

It seems to me the urban / rural split is pretty strong across the country..and so is the old/young split ..

Ak's avatar

My belief is that when they say middle Americans they are politely referring to the non-college graduates with a lower IQ that get swept up in the cult mentality and the FU approach that gains Americans nothing. That does not mean that the majority living and working in middle America are like that. Not at all. I also believe that swing voters are people that pick what they believe will be the lesser evil of two candidates. Unfortunately that’s how the last election went, and look at us now sitting in our very expensive shitty diapers, right along with Trump.

Penny Laneheart's avatar

Nicely put! I think college does make a difference, with the focus put on skills that are needed for understanding politics, like analyzing, summarizing, independent thinking, cooperation, reasoning, composition, outlining, reporting, prioritizing — in a structured way. The electives and selectives that teach those things were more valuable to me than majors-related courses.

Patti🇨🇦🌻's avatar

I completely agree with you!

Penny Laneheart's avatar

I just thought it was a good, lively discussion, getting into pros and cons of different political approaches. Did Mike think ppl were mad? I thought it was invigorating. A slightly heated political discussion is far more interesting than some cool, detached presentation— but there aren’t any like that with Waj!! 🤣🔥

Jason's avatar

He was getting a lot of negative comments in the live chat… but I think him and Waj both are experienced enough to take that in stride.

Barbara Craig's avatar

Nope, other way for me. Republicans are TOO protective of each other ansd that is WHY we are in this mess. We have no good reason to tear other democrats apart BECAUSE we are in a critical mess at the moment. Democrats are far too careful with handling all the stuff in-between. Powerful people with enough money can twist people in either party. THAT is my problem. The need for money to stay in power allows people to lose sight of citizens they represent in the process. Dems are too polite with the really bad republican politicians and cabinet members in power when voters are anxious for them to rally around the Constitution and stop the corruption.

LadyLA's avatar

I think voters are being gaslighted and duped by both parties. The American people are being taken for fools. The politicians think we are stupid for falling for all their lies. We’ve been told that we don’t deserve nice things like healthcare care, free education through college, child care, etc. but we can give money to Israel, the war in Iran, and bailouts when banks screw up the economy or now when crypto and AI fail. When are we going to stop taking the cool aid. We need to be smarter than the people that represent us.

Babette Hogan's avatar

Is the fast tracking of AI Data centers equally about getting ahead of regulations by creating posts before they are needed? Perhaps a water rights grab? It’s a familiar play for extractionists as a means of controlling community oversight and to freely Absorb resources.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 16
Comment deleted
Abandoned Afghan Ally's avatar

I agree with you. As an Afghan ally who was left behind, I have a simple hope for American politics please do not forget the people who believed in your promises.

we were told that our service and our friendship with America meant something. Many of us believed it with our whole hearts. But after Afghanistan fell many allies were left behind to face fear and uncertainty. so when I hear Democrats talking about winning back voters I think the answer is simple: show people that you still believe in keeping your word. Listen to ordinary people, fight for them and do not let political power become more important than human beings. That is the kind of politics I would trust.

Penny Laneheart's avatar

It meant something to the citizens. We believed them too. Look where we are now.

Laurie Stricks's avatar

I think that no matter what, the democratic party needs to support Angie Nixon. Don't abandon Florida. That makes no sense

Cyn's avatar

Massie introduced Articles Of Impeachment against Secretary Of War today

Marion's avatar

Now is our time to go big and put in people that will actually work for the things we want!

Jane Burns's avatar

I would just tell Mike “If you do what you always done, you gonna get what you always got”

elliottoberman's avatar

Mike has issues with the left,I mean Abdul El-Sayed is a DR., a intelligent person, got out raised 60 million and won the primary and he is talking like it was just ok, it was a miracle.

Ramona McGown's avatar

I think Mike is rascist and doesn’t know it

Mary Jane Braddock's avatar

I dunno. I was disappointed in Mike for championing centrist talking points. I understand his argument that we need centrists to win (that's one strategy; the other is to convert centrists to progressives) but by constantly defending centrist ideology and positions, you are effectively a centrist! Mike needs to defending progressives at every turn and educating centrists.

Felicia Thomas's avatar

That’s what I was thinking! He doesn’t encourage centrists to think about what progressives care about. It’s always about us swallowing the centrist narrative. Plus, he left AIPAC out of his list of who dems shouldn’t take money from. Only included AI and crypto. What good will it do if we “win” if all we get is the status quo?

Nita R's avatar

Need more progressive House leader in the future

Jan's avatar

I respect both of your opinions. You keep us up to date on news and what we need to do to make things better. Thank you!

Jodi's avatar

I think centrists don't dare rock the boat. They are too darn comfortable with the status quo.

Declan's avatar

The reason Dems must adopt centrist positions "ro win" is because for decades they never articulated social democrat/progressive positions.. Like Europe and Canada have

Laurie Stricks's avatar

Do we have any evidence that McConnell can speak?

Marion's avatar

Thanks Mike and lol I DO listen to both of you❤️

EdieO's avatar

Mike does understand how politics work. We may not like what he's saying but he's on the inside of the machine and knows what we have to do to take the majority in November. it might require a compromise at some level right now, but better to compromise and take the majority in both houses and then make the changes we're in an urgent situation.We have got to take the midterms. My only concern is that the people who win will not step up to the plate and do what needs to be done. It's going to be tough, it's going to be ugly but it has to happen.

Groovy Dave's avatar

Waj, what you said about how Democrats need to be aggressive and on the attack is so important. Do I wish it weren't that way? No. I wish we were all more cordial and only stuck to policies. But the GOP has made that impossible. So either we accept "liberal" and "progressive" as insults or we embrace the labels and turn it around.