97 Comments
User's avatar
Ben Goldstine's avatar

In a world where Jews cannot be targeted without a collective movement to victim blame, be like Ahmed al Ahmad. 43 year old father of two and fruit shop owner — with zero military training or experience with guns, while at least 4 cops on the scene were hiding — he put his life on the line to save strangers.

I’d like to see Antizionists loudly condemning both this attack on unarmed Jews celebrating Hanukkah, and especially their fellow Antizionists who are blaming the victims of this terrorism. But since that’s not going to happen — at least not from any prominent Antizionist leaders — I will settle for the glorification of courageous hero Ahmed al Ahmad. Nobody will ever know how many lives he saved.

Wishing a speedy recovery to all injured victims of this terrorist attack. Most especially, a speedy recovery to Ahmed al Ahmad, who apparently was shot twice in the arm by another shooter after he disarmed one of them.

Potter's avatar

Anti Zionism comes in many forms and I don't think it's useful to support another broad nebulous enemy using this term. People who are not Zionist or who are Anti Israel are not defacto antiSemitic. Let's find out what's behind this horrific act.

Ben Goldstine's avatar

Can you find me any Antizionist leaders who condemn not just this act of terrorism, but also specifically condemns the overwhelming majority of Antizionist leaders who are blaming Zionism for this mass killing of Jews in Australia?

Literally one?

I don’t mean random Antizionist, I mean someone with a major following and is outspokenly Antizionist. If you can find me literally one, I will vastly reconsider my broad condemnation of Antizionism.

I love Wajahat. I read his book cover to cover, and it made me both laugh and cry. It also gave me a newfound sense of hope and faith in our country. But his commendable condemnation of this act of terrorism does not include condemning the many Antizionist leaders who are “condemning” out of one side of their mouth while blaming Zionism for antisemitic violence. As far as I’m aware, he has never condemned the victim blaming that Antizionists always do after random unarmed Jews are targeted for murder.

I also don’t really consider Wajahat an Antizionist. I would guess that he wouldn’t know if he’d self identify as such either, although what do I know. But I’ve seen him promote a two state solution on a number of occasions, and I’ve never once seen him dehumanize any group of people. Including Zionist Jews and/or Israelis. I don’t know of any outspokenly Antizionist influencer/leader — “we don’t want no two state, we want all of 48” and “from water to water, Palestine is Arab” — who has ever once suggested being open to a two state solution.

Last point: Antizionism isn’t antisemitism, but I think the Venn diagram overlap is much bigger than I’d ever thought it was before 10/7. Anti-nationalism is one thing, but hyperfocusing on opposing a very specific nationalism…

Potter's avatar

I have a huge problem with your use of Antizionist.. and AZ leaders. Can you name me who you are talking about? Or is this your label for whoever speaks out criticizing Israel, what it has been doing, including for decades. I happen to be Jewish. I am not anti-Israel. I am anti what the right wing in Israel is doing and what is happening to the country. The Zionism that my grandma supported is not this. I don't support *this* form of Zionism defined as such. There is more than one Zionism, if you know the history and politics which you should. I think you should clean up your language and accusations. Jews, many, are against what Israel has been doing. And leaders in Israel are anti-Islamic.

*This horrific act is new*. Don't give me an assignment to find those who are what YOU call Antizionist are condemning this in order to prove YOUR point.

DavidPageYea🐝's avatar

I praise your efforts to reason with him, but let me just put this forth: Ben Goldstine is full of shit.

I'm willing to bet he is a zionist, subtly pushing the #1 Israeli narrative that Israel is too sacred to criticize because "if you attack Israel, you are attacking all Jews" [I didn't have the patience to read through his long windedness nor your response; the first 2 lines he said were enough.].

We saw this same sort of garbage rhetoric in the aftermath of 9/11 "Why are the leaders of Islam not condemning these attacks...".

Ben Goldstine's avatar

Potter: Nerdeen of WOL, Mohammed El-Kurd, Remi Kanazi… I could keep going, trust me.

Either admit that prominent Antizionists — people with large followings who oppose a two state solution because they believe Israel should not exist — never encountered a murder of Jews they didn’t blame on Zionism, or give me an example to the contrary.

Potter's avatar

Just focussing on this from you:

Last point: Antizionism isn’t antisemitism, but I think the Venn diagram overlap is much bigger than I’d ever thought it was before 10/7. Anti-nationalism is one thing, but hyperfocusing on opposing a very specific nationalism…"

There is no question that the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas attack brought this festering conflict, ongoing for decades, to what some legitimately call "genocide" now to a real head, not only for the Palestinians. It boomeranged onto the Israelis themselves. They are not winning this. In fact they are losing, including losing Jews.. And so the term Antizionism has new and righteous meaning. After so many years of this it becomes apparent who and what the malign force is in this. The cries "from the river to the sea" of one side have become the cries of the other side... the more powerful.

Some see that October 7th attack as a continuation of the Palestinian fight "to breathe free" with the only means they have, usurped as terrorism. That changes things. Some see Israel using state terrorism against it so much more powerfully. And the world is helpless because of US here choosing sides.

But you brought this up. And I am apologizing to Wajahat now. I will end this.

Ben Goldstine's avatar

There has absolutely NOT been an ongoing genocide for decades. The two year war in Gaza that Hamas started, I’m open to having a discussion. But decades? Absolutely not.

The Arab Palestinian population has consistently outpaced global population rates by 2x-3x times for at least the last 77 years. That is the opposite of “genocide” because words have meanings. Anyone who talks of an ongoing “genocide” for decades ruins the credibility of anyone who wants to try to argue in good faith that Israel’s destruction of Gaza after 10/7 was a genocide.

DavidPageYea🐝's avatar

Hey Ben, have you forgotten that Piss-rael is the worst shit show on the planet? Just wanted to remind you....

Ben Goldstine's avatar

So about finding a single Antizionist who condemns their fellow Antizionists for victim blaming after Jews are murdered…

DavidPageYea🐝's avatar

Ben Goldstine, you can pretend to love Wahajit all you want, but if he thought you were worth his time he'd put you in your place [and it has nothing to do with your being a Jew... or does it?].

Thomas Thompson's avatar

It is indeed ironic that the one person brave enough to wrestle the gun away from a fanatical terrorist was a Muslim himself! It's a small minority of people who hate Jews, but a growing demographic who hate the Israeli government! What they've done in "retaliation" for the attack two years ago is tantamount to attempted genocide, and the use of starvation to kill thousands of Palestinians ranks right up there with the Nazis' worst atrocities!

Sharon C Storm's avatar

It is possible to hate the violence against the Israelis, but to also hate the war against the Palestinians in Gaza. Both types of violence are wrong.

DavidPageYea🐝's avatar

More both sides-ism bullshit. By "violence against Israelis" you are referring to the attacks on October 5th by Hamas? That is less than a bucket of ice in an iceberg when you compare it to what Israel has done since 1948.

Sharon C Storm's avatar

I’m 85, and have been a news junkie all my adult life, so yes, I’m aware of what Israel has done. No violence can be excused, that includes what Hamas has done to the Gazans as well. The October 7th attack was an atrocity just as Netanyahu’s attacks on Gaza are atrocious. I excuse no one except the innocent, especially the children who always suffer more than adults in a war.

Thomas Thompson's avatar

The Palestinian attack two years ago was a desperate attempt to draw the world's attention to the ongoing hatred and subjugation of the Israelis, especially the "settlers" who want the Arabs' lands and crops.

Ben Goldstine's avatar

“To all leaders of Palestinian military, paramilitary and guerrilla organizations; to all soldiers of Palestinian militant groups:

My name is Marek Edelman. I am a former Deputy Commander of the Jewish Military Organization in Poland and one of the leaders of the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising. In the memorable year of 1943 we fought for the survival of the Jewish community in Warsaw. We fought for mere life, not for territory, nor for a national identity. We fought with hopeless determination, but our weapons were never directed against the defenceless civilian population, we never killed women and children. In the world devoid of principles and values, despite a constant danger of death, we did remain faithful to these values and moral principles.

We were isolated in our fight, and yet the powerful opposing army was not able to destroy these barely armed boys and girls. Our fight in Warsaw lasted several weeks, and later we fought in the partisan groups and in the Warsaw Uprising of 1944.

Yet nowhere in the world can urban guerrilla force bring a conclusive victory, but it cannot be defeated by well-armed armies either. And this war will not bring any resolution.

Blood will be spilled in vain and lives will be lost on both sides.

We were never careless with life. We never sent our soldiers to certain death. Life is one for eternity. Nobody has the right to mindlessly take it away. It is high time for everybody to understand that.

Just look around you. Look at Ireland. After 50 years of bloody war, peace has arrived. The former deadly enemies sat down at a common table. Look at Poland, at Walesa and Kuron.

Without a single shot being fired the criminal communist system was defeated. Both you and the State of Israel have to radically change your attitude. You have to want peace in order to save the lives of hundreds or perhaps thousands of people, and to create a better future for your loved ones, for your children. I know from my own experience that the current unfolding of events depends on you, the Military Leaders. The influence of political and civilian actors is much smaller. Some of you studied at the university in my city, some of you know me. You are wise and intelligent enough to understand that without peace there is no future for Palestine, and that peace can be attained only at the cost of both sides agreeing to some concessions.

I also ask President Bill Clinton, Minister Bernard Kouchner and MP Daniel Cohn-Bendit to endorse my appeal. I want to remind you our joint position on the Yugoslavia war.

Maybe this war, in which there will be no winners, can also be stopped and replaced by negotiations leading to peace. Maybe the best mediator would not be a politician but a person of a high moral authority, who values each man’s life in dignity and peace higher than political goals.”

Marek Edelman, August 2002

Steven Robert Levine's avatar

One compassionate human witnessed other humans being gunned down. Maybe he knew they were Jews, maybe he didn't. I don't think he cared. He saw the horror and acted. He realized he had the strength and the element of surprise and he didn't hesitate. Risking his own life, he acted.

He wasn't a "good guy with a gun." He is a good guy with a compassionate heart and mind.

In deep gratitude I say, "Thank you Ahmed!"

Mary McAvoy's avatar

You're echoing my thoughts. Thank you.

DavidPageYea🐝's avatar

Hearing you mention ""good guy with a gun" reminds me of how dishonest that National Rifle Association line really is. We've seen time and time again that gun owners (including cops) overwhelmingly tend to be cowards, leaving it up to unarmed civilians like Almed to do the real work of rescuing those in danger.

During the Uvalde mass shooting, the heavily armed cops took gun owner cowardice to new lows: Not only did they hide behind barricades while the shooter continued to slaughter teachers and kids; they focussed their energy preventing desperate parents from rescuing their children.

KingRayVet's avatar

Why are you fussing? He said that Ahmed WASN'T a good guy with a gun. He didn't have one and took the rifle away from the man who did. Now you're running off on a tangent by selectively leaving that part out. Good God, man, stop it.

DavidPageYea🐝's avatar

You're correct in that I went off on a bit of a tangent. However, I was agreeing with Levine's observation that yet again, the real hero isn't "good guy with a gun".

Carole Langston's avatar

Don't let his name, Almed, fade. Keep repeating it. My husband already is.

TRUTH.

elba's avatar

Thank you for this Wajahat Ali and Ahmad El Ahmed.We desperately need to see/hear/feel that the utterly depraved and foul bigots are not what we're all about, that most humans are still decent.

Kathleen M. Eisenhauer's avatar

You do not people. Hate is being taught and until that stops, we will continue to bear witness to this type of human destruction. Ahmed El Ahmed stood up to evil and is a hero!!!!!

DavidPageYea🐝's avatar

"Hate is being taught"

- Whose hate are you referring to? I personally hate Israel and zionism. I don't consider it having been "taught" me; I gradually changed my opinion away from favoring Israel, after the zionist misinformation curtain was lifted.

Cathy Delia's avatar

Why are these ultra right wingers trying to make us fear Muslims when it's their radicalized base who are the ones we should be afraid of. They are the ones with guns and hate in their hearts.

Pelican's avatar

Well said Waj. This tragedy will strengthen Australian's belief in our right for peace for all.

Marguerite's avatar

Wouldn’t it nice to have a president that condemned this hatred and brought us together. That goes for the republicans in government that could also stop this hatred and speak up. Instead we have bigots.

The man that grabbed the shooter risked his life to stop more people from being killed or wounded. He is such a selfless man and my heart breaks from the hatred they endure.

Jan Bruce's avatar

I was so happy to read this morning that the hero was a Muslim. It is a tragedy to blame an entire religion or group of people for an act of violence perpetrated by a few. From Australia.

George Jackson's avatar

It sure looks like magats are spoiling for a race war.

Dana Bennett's avatar

What a brave man, Ahmed, who just instinctively did the RIGHT thing - helping his fellow citizens! And those weaklings cops - you THINK you get to pick & choose who you help??? I BET you took an oath TO ASSIST all citizens. How’s that working out for you now?? Not so great, I imagine. SHAME on you….

Soulkinetics's avatar

Please don't bash Australian police. Many who attended were off duty, and when they heard a serious situation was unfolding, rushed to the location to assist. Mr Ahmed had an opportunity to come at one of the shooters from behind, and bravely chose to act. Reports indicate two junior officers are in hospital in critical condition, with Scott Dyson, a probationary constable 4 months on the job, shot multiple times in the face.

Au Yeong Soong Kong's avatar

When a heinous mass murder happens I actually feel relieved if the perp is a white man because I know his ethnic group won't be collectively punished or made to apologize for the actions of one. But if an active shooter or stabber is a minority or an immigrant - brace for impact, the right wing reactionaries will exploit the incident for mass demonization.

Charlie's avatar

Yes, but. If any group other than White Men started mass murdering at this same rate-- whether White Women or Black/ Asian Men, we'd have strict gun control in a hurry.

DavidPageYea🐝's avatar

So well said. Also, white rightwing gun owners' entitled behavior suggests great ignorance of the law. The fact that other ethnicities as well as progressives in USA so far have been overwhelmingly loathe to acquire murder weapons doesn't mean necessity can't change.

Cherae Stone's avatar

Thank you, Waj. Keep speaking truth. It matters.

#HoldFast

Andrea Brecker's avatar

In the background is the tragedy that we have come to expect, or at least not be surprised by, gun violence. Yesterday was at minimum a double-header, a shooting at Brown Uni and an attack in Australia on those celebrating Hanukkah. The victims in Australia are not all Jews but Jews were what motivated the shooters. That the smooth brained people who live to hate and immediately rail against Muslims is the tragedy fueled by a man and his morality-free support team. As a Jew, I wish there would be a class action suit from Jews who resent the Administration using “antisemitism” as a reason for doing its dirty deeds. Columbia Uni still has a locked campus. Those of us living in the Columbia neighborhood are not able to walk across the campus on a roadway created for public access. A court case to end closed access continues to be kicked down the road. Columbia has a large budget for lawyers and no appetite for releasing any apartments in their real estate empire to anyone not affiliated with Columbia.

Potter's avatar

Tommy Tuberville member of the Trump cult, is telling us Islam is not a religion? He is instead telling us how ignorant and hateful he is... nothing more. He needs to be unseated. Too bad his opposition just withdrew.

Charlie's avatar

I'll tell you what is NOT a religion:

Nationalist Christianity. And finally, pleasant and good Christians are publicly saying it.

John Fugelsang's "Separation of Church and Hate: A sane person's guide to taking back the Bible from fundamentalists, fascists, and flock fleecing frauds" is a great read, informative and funny.

Deborah solleveld's avatar

I don’t understand. Doug jones is running against him for governor.

Potter's avatar

You are right. I was mistaken about what person just bowed out. Doug Jones is a great candidate.

DavidPageYea🐝's avatar

Does Tubberville have to abandon his seat in congress to run for governor? A: No he does not! So yes, Tubberville will remain a problem whether he becomes governor or not.

Pamela Fender's avatar

It was probably another repug who dropped from the race

pammyjo30's avatar

I have a really hard time understanding how anyone can hate another person simply because of skin color, sexual orientation, religion, or anything else. We are all different, and that's what makes life interesting.

I especially don't understand the urge to kill another person. What's wrong with live and let live? So your neighbors are Muslim, and you're Christian. Are they hurting you? Then leave them alone. Or, better yet, invite them for dinner. I bet they're pretty cool people.

Something needs to be done about these mass shootings besides thoughts and prayers.

DavidPageYea🐝's avatar

To me, hatred tends to stem from indignation at the perceived crimes of others. Or it can come from fear of competition. Though "hate" is reflexively postulated by observers, I rarely see proof that a mass shooter had hatred in either of these senses [What could a classroom full of 6 years olds possibly have done to make one hate them?].

I would argue that there are some for whom cruelty is the point; they thoroughly enjoy witnessing and promoting the suffering of others, whoever they might be, and this extends to hurting animals as well.

There is a member of my family whose' consistent cruelty over long decades, stemming from earliest childhood, has led to the rest of us eventually throwing up our hands and shunning him. He's also lost friends over this; but the reward in his gluttony for sadism is well worth it to him. I wouldn't call him insane either, for he's cleverly always kept it legal and managed to take relatively good care of himself .

Thanks to the internet, one can always locate like minded individuals to bond with so one doesn't feel isolated, no matter how deplorable one's outlook may be. And no, I don't believe any form of censorship is the answer. That was tried with Q-Anon and it failed miserably.